Reviews

Based on 61 reviews
98%
(60)
2%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
Right up my alley

It's not just any bottle, it's a single barrel cask strength bottle from Bardstown.

What a deal!

Being able to use points and add bottles to my club pick orders is the best thing to ever happen!

The 11 is better, but this isn’t far away. Great pick.

Crushable

This is so good and easy to drink. Summer bourbon.

Another Sagamore winner!

I’m a big fan of Sagamore, it’s one of my favorite distilleries. This WCWC pick is no exception. An amazing rye with all the right flavors, awesome nose and great finish.

Get Some KC

Great pick by WCW team. Love it

Great Juice!

Get a back up

Absolute Banger!

This is sweet, fruit forward, and flavor packed pick just keeps giving!

Great pick

Great flavors in this pick.

WOW!

Absolutely love this pick! I'm no expert in singling out flavors but man this is delicious. I get slightly sweet brown sugar/caramel and super smooth finish.

Perfect pour

I thought the 120 proof was good, this is steps above in so many ways. Great barrel pick.

Awesome

I love everything you guys pick. Can’t wait for the next one.

A+++ Hazmat

Absolutely delicious and surprising drinks under the proof point. Highly recommend!!

Not your average Makers

This is classic Makers Mark but cranked up several notches with more complexity. On the palate I get orange rind, honey, caramel, clove nutmeg and dark chocolate. If you like Makers Mark or classic bourbon flavors, you’ll love this.

130 proof legit competition!

It’s like someone dropped a flavor grenade in my mouth! Pull the pin!

Wow!

These Nashville picks keep getting better. It’s like Christmas in my mouth!

Going to need a backup of this

If you liked the first Nashville pick WCWC did, this is right up your alley. Dark sugary notes, old leather, baking spices and fruit notes. Wow is this good!

Perfect “easy-drinker”

This has become one of my new “everyday” pours. It’s sweet and has a nice complexity. Drinks below the proof and is “crushable.” This one comes with a cool tater sticker and Master Distiller Stephen Beam approved this pick. Great bottle!

Drinks under the proof

If you’re looking for a complex and interesting whiskey, this is a roller coaster! Adding a drop of water opens this up to a wild ride that drinks more like that hazmat proof. But neat or on the rocks this is gorgeous. Worth the price tag!

Peanut brittle bomb

This has the classic notes of Knob Creek but cranked up a notch with pronounced sweet peanut brittle, oak, a mild cinnamon that drinks near-proof. I’m going to need a back up of this one.

Drinks under proof

If you’re looking for a complex and interesting whiskey, this is a roller coaster! Adding a drop of water opens this up to a wild ride that drinks more like that hazmat proof. But near or on the rocks this is gorgeous. Worth the price tag!

Dessert in a Glass — Without Overdoing It

One of my favorite bottles to wind down the day with. The balance between the crème brûlée sweetness and the whiskey itself is spot on — neither overwhelms the other. Just a smooth, easy finisher that's hard to beat.

A Pour Worth Revisiting Again and Again

Delicious pour — went back to the well several times for refills. The proof is spot on, offering just the right balance of warmth without overpowering. The profile is smooth and layered throughout, making it an easy standout. Well done!

A great pick.

Dig the bottle. Nice & smooth with a sweet finish.